Joseph O'Connor on an assured narrative that moves between fascist Italy and modern Ireland
25 July 2009
The Irish author Christine Dwyer Hickey achieved a breakthrough with her last book, Tatty, a finely crafted story that seemed part novel, part memoir, and was longlisted for the Orange prize. Along with Hugo Hamilton's The Speckled People, it inaugurated a radically new way of writing about Irish childhoods. In Last Train From Liguria she broadens her ground. This is a big, bold, remarkably assured narrative that roams between 1930s London and Celtic Tiger-era Dublin, cleverly shifting its balance of perspectives and characterisations so that both those places lead inevitably to the fascist-era Italy that is really the novel's main setting.
Last Train From Liguria
by Christine Dwyer Hickey
390pp, Atlantic, £12.99
1933, Bella Stuart, the introspective daughter of a London surgeon, sets out for the country where Mr Mussolini is busy making the trains run on time. The plan is for her to be tutor to the son of the aristocratic Lami family - "there's a villa in Sicily and a summer house on the Italian riviera", and there is "some German connection, so you'll probably be popping off to Berlin". Fateful words for the whole of Europe, perhaps.
Signora Lami turns out to be younger than Bella, her husband much older, a man who has "a face that is ready to die". There is a scene of Tolstoyan poignancy and unearthly beauty where Bella glimpses them bathing. This is a household as strange as it is crustily sumptuous. Its mistress refers to the servants as "frightful primitives". Even the sound made by the crickets seems different, somehow: "harsher and slightly neurotic".
Literary images of Italy are so much a part of western aesthetic inheritance, and have been since at least the era of the European grand tour, that they have become almost bomb-proof by now. Storytellers engaging with that extraordinarily complicated country's realities have occasionally seemed to be writing about a stage set. ("All that art and sunshine," Bella's father remarks, as wowed as a prototype Merchant-Ivory executive.)
Yet anyone who knows the real place has often been struck by the extent to which Italy is itself a work of fiction, an anthology of widely disparate and often avowedly inimical cultures yoked together by 19th-century nationalism. Dwyer Hickey's prose, in its suppleness and mordant grace, incarnates an Italy that is beautiful but not so photogenic, and not to be found in Baedeker.
As the ugly wrigglings of fascism become ever more pernicious, there is a sense of a world that is inexorably corrupting but still holding its shape. Images of ageing and amnesia abound. Sickness is a kind of inheritance. Dwyer Hickey builds the book slowly, stirring layers of the past into the mix, so that a killing that happened in Dublin at the outset of the novel's narrative becomes an essential element of the plot. Perhaps a little implausibly, the killer has fled to southern Italy - but you are willing to meet the author halfway when required, for the spellbinding acuity of her language.
When she writes about the Mediterranean light and the food and the worldview, about the people's
When the husband of the enigmatic Signora Lami dies, their son, Allesandro, is sent with troubled Bella to the wonderfully conveyed town of Bordighera. Here they fall in with a strange music teacher, Maestro Edward, and the remarkably observed shifts in this triangle of loss and yearning are never once overwritten. Dwyer Hickey's gift for lyricism is scrupulously deployed, but she is careful never to sink her characters by describing them too richly: it is her great skill to stand out of their way.
This would be a solid piece of work if it had settled for the relative safety of the historical novel; the book's cinematic capaciousness and striking confidence would have made it an impressively page-turning read. What makes it darker and stranger is its framing character, Anna, a woman of Italian descent living in Dublin in 1995, where "the lazy brass music of Coronation Street from the telly" is about as Joycean as things ever get.
With great subtlety and skill, connections are uncovered, so that present and past become metaphors of one another, and the life of Bordighera echoes uneasily across the decades with the now imploded grandiosities of Celtic Tiger Ireland. Tactically, this is a master stroke, for it bursts the book out of the museum of exhausting accuracies that is always lying in wait for the historical novelist. What emerges is a powerfully accomplished work of art. In the end, this isn't a novel about politics or history. It's a wrenchingly affecting love story of compromised identities and regrets, of adult realisations and broken hopes, as hesitatingly wise as it is moving and persuasive.
• Joseph O'Connor's novel Redemption Falls is published by Vintage.