Perjury (Part Five): Ward Churchill’s “Sourcing” for his Smallpox Blankets Claim

Perjury (Part Five): Ward Churchill's "Sourcing" for his Smallpox Blankets Claim

By Alex ConstantineChurchill's courtroom comments on the introduction of smallpox-infected blankets to the Indians by the U.S. Army:

...I've been hearing this all my life from traditional sources and mainstream sources. It's enshrined in songs and oral traditions specific to the Mandan. ... Churchill said he's attended several speaking engagements since the misconduct allegations arose and people are stunned when he tells them that he is accused of making up facts about smallpox being introduced by the Army, something he considers common knowledge. ... "http://www.denverpost.com/commented/ci_11977426?source=commented-newsChurchill considers the smallpox blanket story to be "common knowledge" - yet resorted to inventing sources to document it, despite his sworn misstatements: "... Churchill cited Evan S. Connell's Son of the Morning Star: Custer and the Little Big Horn and Russell Thornton’s American Indian Holocaust and Survival but neither book says anything about the army playing such a role. ... "http://www.columbia.edu/~lnp3/mydocs/indian/ThomasBrown2.htmCommentary:Re: "Jury to have last word on Churchill’s suit vs. CU," March 9 news story.Denver PostI am a retired teacher with a master’s degree in American studies focusing on outdoor museum management, more than 60 graduate hours, and many hours of study and experience as a volunteer at such sites as Bent’s Old Fort and Fort Laramie. Ward Churchill is an embarrassment to all who strive for accuracy and truth in Western American history.For example, the canard regarding the distribution of smallpox-infected blankets to the Indians by the Army was refuted years ago, as Mr. Churchill should have known had he been an adequate student and researcher. Couldn’t he find a more original lie?If Mr. Churchill wanted to make his mark, why didn’t he pursue the yet-to-be-written history of some of our forgotten Western citizens — women, the Hispanics who actually built Bent’s Old Fort, the Native Americans/Indians/First Americans (take your pick) who kept commerce flowing there, even Dick and Charlotte Green, William Bent’s slaves — instead of masking his arrogance and lack of scholarship in the guise of academic freedom?Dan McCrimmon, Littletonhttp://blogs.denverpost.com/eletters/2009/03/14/ward-churchill’s-trial-5-letters/PART SIX...

Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "Perjury (Part Five): Ward Churchill’s “Sourcing” for his Smallpox Blankets Claim"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Lyle Courtsal
Guest
Ward Churchill is using whay are called in the journalism business “primary sources”. Do you like to recognize the truth about how horrific the largest continuous mass slaughter in history. If it is a tribal story that is passed down through the generations is it any less valid than the writng of it in a book? Whether it was intentional or “accidental”, the truth is our germs killed their people and we didn’t care because us nice white gentiles said they were “savages” and so it was OK for us nice white anti-christians to let them die or kill them… Read more »
Lyle Courtsal
Guest

Third World Quarterly vol23,#6 PP 1159-1179 article by Ian Martinez.

wpDiscuz